‘Gilmore Girls’: Did Amy Sherman-Palladino Want to Destroy Rory Gilmore?

by Jeremy Spirogis
2019 In Review: The Best Pop Culture-Inspired Sneakers of the Year

Gilmore Girls: A Year within the Life was supposed to supply
, and Gilmore Girls followers some closure. The collection
was beloved throughout its authentic run, and a big cult following developed when
the collection grew to become obtainable for streaming on Netflix. The revival was purported to
tie up unfastened ends and provide Sherman-Palladino the chance to inform the story
she by no means acquired to inform. Something about it, nonetheless, simply felt misplaced, so
a lot in order that followers have questioned if Sherman-Palladino was making an attempt to destroy
the beloved character of Rory

Rory appeared like a really misplaced soul in A Year within the Life

While the Netflix revival acquired general optimistic critiques,
diehard followers noticed evident points. They couldn’t put their finger on what precisely
was mistaken. Something simply felt somewhat bit off. After a couple of re-watch,
the overarching downside with the revival was Rory.

Rory appeared completely different, however not in the best way that you simply’d anticipate.
She was no wiser than when followers left her again in 2007. She hadn’t progressed,
modified, or developed from the 22-year-old she was so a few years earlier than. She
wasn’t even cynical and weathered by time, like somebody who had been crushed
down by an expert world that didn’t welcome her with open arms. She merely
appeared caught. The closing 4 phrases of the collection did little to bolster opinions
of the as soon as golden baby of Stars
, both. So, what’s the deal? Was Sherman-Palladino making an attempt to destroy
the character she so lovingly created?

 Amy Sherman-Palladino
as soon as argued that she believes persons are born evil

One of essentially the most troubling points of A Year within the Life
for followers was Rory’s
complete inability to empathize with others
. If we’re sincere, although, Rory
all the time appeared to have somewhat little bit of a problem with empathy, no matter how
many instances she was touted as candy and agreeable. Her youthful exuberance and
studious nature merely masked her incapacity to be really variety to others.

Rory’s shortcomings, which had been on full displaying in Gilmore Girls: A Year within the Life, probably had been by design. Sherman-Palladino has a powerful perception that persons are inherently evil. At least, that’s what she informed the New Statesman. In a prolonged interview, she informed the publication that she believes that persons are born inherently evil and it’s important to “beat goodness into them.” Perhaps, that’s what A Year within the Life confirmed; Rory by no means had that stage of goodness crushed into her.

So, was Sherman-Palladino making an attempt to destroy Rory?

It doesn’t seem to be it. In truth, what Sherman-Palladino did
with Rory’s character could have been a contact of genius that merely got here on the
mistaken time. Rory was purported to be misplaced and confused. She was purported to be
somebody whose life didn’t pan out the best way she anticipated, no matter her greatest
efforts at protected and well-researched decision-making. The takeaway appears easy:
irrespective of how a lot you propose, life can take you down a completely surprising

Most followers appear to have a problem with Rory’s habits within the revival because it pertains to her age. In A Year within the Life, Rory was 10 years out of faculty, on the mistaken aspect of 30. The missteps she made through the revival simply didn’t really feel just like the errors of a 30-something. They had been the errors of a naive 22-year-old, as a result of, on the finish of the day, that’s what Sherman-Palladino all the time meant.  

The revival adopted the storyline she deliberate to develop
for the present’s closing season. The closing 4 phrases uttered by Rory within the revival
was the best way Sherman-Palladino all the time needed the story to finish. That ending, with
Rory as a 22-year-old latest graduate, would have probably sat effectively with followers. At
32, nonetheless, it simply appeared to fall flat, and every part that was wanted to get
Rory from level A to level B made her fairly unbearable, from her remedy
of Paul,
to the affair with Logan, to the dearth of gainful employment.

Leave a Comment