‘Gilmore Girls’: Fans Found Luke’s Secret Love Child Unbelievable

by Jeremy Spirogis
April Nardini and Rory Gilmore in

Gilmore Girls followers have been largely pleased with how the sequence performed out, however one storyline appears to stay out to followers as nearly completely unbelievable. During season 6, Luke Danes discovers that he has a secret 12-year-old baby. The discovery results in the top of Luke and Lorelai Gilmore’s engagement. While the top of the engagement didn’t sit effectively with viewers, many followers had an even bigger concern with how the April Nardini storyline was written into the sequence.

April Nardini was launched to smash Luke and Lorelai’s relationship

Luke and Lorelai’s relationship was going swimmingly till April confirmed up on the scene. After her sudden look, issues went downhill for Luke and Lorelai fairly rapidly. In the top, her existence in his life is what triggered Lorelai to present Luke an ultimatum about their marriage. That ultimatum led to the top of their engagement.

April Nardini and Rory Gilmore in 'Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life'
April Nardini and Rory Gilmore in ‘Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life’ | Netflix

RELATED: ‘Gilmore Girls’: Did You Ever Notice How Rarely The Words “I Love You” Are Spoken?

April was written into the present by Amy Sherman-Palladino to smash Luke and Lorelai’s relationship. The secret baby and the best way Luke dealt with it was the one factor that would have damaged up the pair. While most followers perceive why she was added to the present, they discover the best way she was added largely troublesome to take care of.

Fans don’t purchase the best way April popped up within the sequence

April confirmed up at Luke’s Diner to ask for a paternity take a look at. April wasn’t desirous about truly discovering her father. Rather, she wished to win a science honest. Her mom, who should have fastidiously curated her life to make sure she by no means bumped into Luke, regardless of residing inside biking distance of his diner, apparently had no clue about April’s venture. Eventually, Luke finds out he’s April’s father and units out to have a relationship along with her. In doing so, he decides to cover April’s existence from Lorelai then pushes Lorelai away when she does finally uncover the massive secret.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=videoseries[embedded content material]

There are a ton of issues with the storyline. Aside from the various, many plot holes, the story simply doesn’t match. The April storyline appears to be ripped from the pages of a cleaning soap opera script as an alternative of a sitcom script about a mother-daughter duo. The proven fact that Sherman-Palladino didn’t take the logistics of the state of affairs under consideration trouble’s followers, however most agree {that a} secret baby storyline may have labored, simply not the best way Sherman-Palladino employed it.

Fans may have accepted a secret baby if it had been finished in a different way

Fans appear to agree that Luke’s secret baby wasn’t the issue. Instead, they largely agree that the best way it was written into the sequence was questionable. Gilmore Girls viewers would have discovered the storyline simpler to swallow if it had been finished in a totally totally different manner.

Lorelai Gilmore andf Luke Danes in 'Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life' Lorelai Gilmore andf Luke Danes in 'Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life'
Lorelai Gilmore and Luke Danes in ‘Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life’ | Netflix

RELATED: ‘Gilmore Girls’: Was Kirk Gleason Planted In Stars Hollow as a Spy?

One Reddit person instructed having Rachel come again with a secret child would have made a ton extra sense. At the very least, it might have been a bit simpler for followers to take care of. Rachel, Luke’s girlfriend throughout season 1 of the present, was no less than identified to followers. It would have been plausible for her to have had a baby after she left Stars Hollow. The proven fact that Luke dated Anna Nardini earlier than the present began troubled viewers. Add in the truth that she raised a baby for 12 years, simply two cities away with out anybody understanding it, appears largely unbelievable. Overall, the storyline felt like a missed alternative. 

Leave a Comment