John Lennon: The Bob Dylan Album He Said Wasn’t Authentically Dylan

by Jeremy Spirogis
John Lennon: The Bob Dylan Album He Said Wasn’t Authentically Dylan

John Lennon and Bob Dylan have been contemporaries. It’s unimaginable to really perceive the evolution of John’s profession with out understanding Dylan’s affect on it. However, that doesn’t imply John favored all the things Dylan did.

In a well-known 1971 interview, John discussed an enormous vary of matters, together with a number of current albums from 1960s rock gods. In the interview, he discussed Dylan’s most up-to-date album. John was not a fan.

Bob Dylan with a guitar | Bettmann / Contributor

A a lot derided Bob Dylan album and its acclaimed follow-up

According to Ultimate Classic Rock, Dylan launched the album Self-Portrait in 1970. It was an experiment – to say the least. First of all, it had a portray on its cowl which appeared downright amateurish. The tracklisting was largely covers of different folks’s songs, in addition to a couple of remakes of Dylan tracks.

It was an odd transfer to call the album Self-Portrait contemplating Dylan didn’t write a lot of the songs on it. According to AllMusic, followers of Dylan discovered the album disappointing and it failed commercially. AllMusic even theorized the album was deliberately dangerous. However, issues bought higher for Dylan.

His following album, New Morning, was a return to type for the singer. It did effectively critically and commercially. It contains one in all Dylan’s most beloved and well-known songs: “If Not for You.” The nation monitor was lined by two very completely different common musicians: George Harrison and Olivia-Newton John.

John Lennon weighs in on ‘New Morning’

[embedded content material]

‘If Not for You” by Bob Dylan

RELATED: Are Timothée Chalamet and Bob Dylan Friends?

John, nonetheless, wasn’t impressed. He informed Rolling Stone New Morning wasn’t particular, however added he could have felt that manner as a result of he anticipated an excessive amount of from Dylan. He additionally admitted he wasn’t as desirous about Dylan’s music as he as soon as was.

John elaborated on his emotions in regards to the Dylan catalog. “I liked ‘Rolling Stone’ and a few things he did then; I like a few things he did in the early days. The rest of it is just like Lennon-McCartney or something. It’s no different, its a myth.”

It’s not clear what John was saying when he known as the Lennon-McCartney and Dylan catalogs have been a “myth.” Was he dismissing the concept these catalogs have been good as a fantasy? That interpretation feels a bit troublesome to subscribe to, contemplating how John complimented lots of the songs from his Beatles days.

The hit John Lennon most popular to ‘New Morning’

[embedded content material]

‘I Hear You Knocking” by Dave Edmunds

RELATED: Beatles: Why Bob Dylan Felt They Ripped Him Off With ‘Norwegian Wood’

Later within the interview, Jann Wenner requested John if he felt New Morning was a brand new morning for Dylan. “No, It might be a new morning for him because he stopped singing on the top of his voice. It’s all right, but it’s not him, it doesn’t mean a f*cking thing. I’d sooner have ‘I Hear You Knocking’ by Dave Edmunds, it’s the top of England now.”

“I Hear You Knocking” is a throwback to 1950s rock ‘n’ roll. John mentioned elsewhere within the interview he favored that style most of all. Edmunds definitely has followers. However, many Dylan followers can be shocked to know John favored “I Hear You Knocking” higher than an acclaimed Dylan album.

Also see: Beatles: Why Bob Dylan Said ‘Yesterday’ & ‘Michelle’ Are ‘Cop-Outs’

Leave a Comment