Mark Ruffalo vs. Edward Norton: Fans Decide Who Portrayed a Better Bruce Banner, The Scientist

by Jeremy Spirogis
Mark Ruffalo onstage

In a combat of the MCU Hulks, who would come out on high? By most measures, Mark Ruffalo would. Generally talking, followers have favored his portrayal, particularly because the Hulk bought extra vocal in later motion pictures.

Edward Norton has hardly an opportunity, contemplating he solely appeared because the Hulk as soon as, and in a film usually named because the MCU’s weakest. 

However, that’s should you’re speaking concerning the portrayal of the Hulk, or of Bruce Banner because the tortured offended man. If you’re speaking about Bruce Banner the scientist, nonetheless, then Norton may even have the sting. 

Mark Ruffalo onstage
MARK RUFFALO | CRAIG SJODIN by way of Getty Images

‘The Incredible Hulk’ can’t catch a break 

The success of the MCU in recent times has grow to be so dominant that it’s straightforward to neglect that Phase 1 had its tough patches. And the roughest patch of all, box-office smart, was 2008’s The Incredible Hulk. 

The MCU had exploded out of the gate with Iron Man, which made $318 million, however The Incredible Hulk, launched just one month later, made simply $134 million. That’s barely higher than the 2003 film’s $132 million, and it’s the low-water mark for the franchise, with the second-lowest grosser being Captain America: The First Avenger, with $176 million.

Quality-wise, the film didn’t stack up with critics or audiences. The Incredible Hulk ties with Thor: The Dark World on the Rotten Tomatoes scale, with 67 and 66 p.c, respectively.

It isn’t hated, per se, however the Critical Consensus reads, “The Incredible Hulk will not be fairly the smashing success that followers of Marvel’s raging behemoth may hope for, however it gives greater than sufficient huge inexperienced motion to make up for its often puny narrative.”

Edward Norton often is the higher Banner

[embedded content]

So, strike a number of in opposition to the Norton Hulk. However, followers on Reddit had been extra forgiving, One fan stated,

“I actually liked Ed Norton’s Bruce Banner better than Mark Ruffalo’s 🙂 Ruffalo did a better job playing “member of The Avengers who turns into the Hulk” than Norton would’ve (Norton wouldn’t have had the identical chemistry with Downey Jr, Evans, Johansson…), however Norton did a greater job of enjoying “Bruce Banner, scientist” Ruffalo’s Banner felt like “A Scientist” in The Avengers, however in each film after that, he solely felt like “a guy who does science.”

In equity to Ruffalo, The Avengers was the one film through which Ruffalo actually bought to play scientist Bruce Banner, to determine him as a distinction to Tony Stark’s techno-genius. However, he has a special vitality than Norton. Ruffalo performs up the “I’m always angry” idea, whereas Norton, maybe due to his slighter construct, comes throughout as extra of an educational.

Ruffalo bought to play scientist extra with Avengers: Endgame, notably in how he needed to clarify to the opposite Avengers that point journey doesn’t observe Back to the Future logic.

However, that’s when he had grow to be “Professor Hulk, ” a model of the character a number of followers haven’t warmed as much as. That may additionally play into the notion of Norton as the higher scientist as a result of he didn’t must take care of the conflict of photos as Ruffalo did. 

The Hulk that may have been and should still be 

[embedded content]

Behind the scenes, Norton has a fame for being demanding and wanting extra management over his characters. It was stated that he and Marvel parted methods over artistic variations. Norton revealed final 12 months he needed to create a darker tackle the Hulk, like one thing Christopher Nolan might need made. However, Marvel finally didn’t agree with that route, leaving followers to marvel “what if?”

They is likely to be questioning that about Ruffalo too, however another way. Ruffalo himself has stated he didn’t see the place the Hulk would match after the conclusion of the Infinity Saga, however there was speak that he would take part within the She-Hulk TV present that’s being developed.

Or maybe in the future the rights points with Universal may very well be labored out, and Ruffalo may get his personal Hulk film. Third time’s the attraction?

Leave a Comment