No, Ben Solo's Fate Should Not Be Reversed In Future Star Wars Stories

by Jeremy Spirogis
Kylo Ren Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker

Warning! The following accommodates spoilers for Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker. Read at your individual danger!

Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker had its justifiable share of critics, although it is secure to say few had been as sore concerning the film because the Reylo folks. The fandom, which is known as after their love and help of a romantic relationship between Rey and Kylo Ren, discovered itself divided in its emotions following the film, which lastly noticed Rey and Ben Solo share a kiss. Soon after that although, Ben died, and lots of felt Disney ruined the character’s likelihood for real love and redemption.

I imagine Reylo followers have a proper to be upset, although I additionally preserve that Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker made the appropriate name in killing off Ben. Letting him survive in any case that occurred within the film would’ve been a horrible mistake, and never one Disney ought to ever contemplate altering. When it involves future Star Wars tales, Ben Solo is healthier off lifeless.

Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker

Wait, Ben Solo Could Come Back?

Indeed. While a majority of deaths (save one very huge one) in Star Wars are remaining, there’s a approach for Ben Solo to return though he appeared about as lifeless as one will be. Exegol is a planet that exists within the World Between Worlds. In this zone, the Force is at its strongest, and the principles of the way it works are bizarre and never solely concrete.

All we all know is that Anakin Skywalker as soon as introduced Ahsoka Tano again to life in one in all these zones in Star Wars: The Clone Wars, in order that’s a factor that may occur. Take that and pair it with the truth that Ben’s Force Ghost didn’t seem alongside Luke and Leia on the finish of The Rise of Skywalker, and there is a official and canon pleasant concept that Ben Solo might be introduced again to life. So sure, it is a factor that may really occur, even when it should not.

Ben Solo Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker

Ben Solo Received About As Much Redemption As He Could Realistically Get

Ben Solo might not have gotten the redemption some wished, however he acquired redemption nontheless. He managed to reconcile his guilt for killing his father, headed to Exegol to assist Rey, and performed a key position in making certain her survival within the remaining battle. If killing the Emperor was all it took for Darth Vader’s redemption, then Ben Solo was redeemed.

Say Ben survived following the Emperor’s destruction; do he and Rey reside fortunately ever after? Absolutely not. Ben could also be redeemed and beloved within the eyes of Rey, however to a bulk of the galaxy far, far-off, he is the Hitler-like determine chargeable for a lot of the destruction attributable to the First Order. Supporters of the Resistance would completely need Kylo Ren tried for his warfare crimes, no matter whether or not or not he was the kid of Han Solo and Leia Organa. Rey supporting him wouldn’t be look and would probably flip others in opposition to her as properly.

Even if Rey turned her again on the Resistance to be with Ben, the 2 couldn’t reside a lifetime of peace. Both would eternally be an enemy to what stays of the First Order and Sith Loyal, which implies a lifetime of being on the run and searching over ones shoulder. That’s not a life many individuals would want on others, so I’m inclined to suppose a reformed Ben would abandon all hope of an actual life with Rey post-The Rise of Skywalker.

Ben Solo Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker

We Really Have No Guarantee Rey And Ben Could’ve Had An Actual Relationship

There’s no denying the sexual stress between Rey and Ben that started in Star Wars: The Last Jedi and continued in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. There’s one thing there, but ultimately, Ben dies shortly after the 2 share their first kiss. This is a part of the grievance some Reylo shippers have, as they had been robbed of the connection simply because it appeared to get going.

That’s assuming there was an actual relationship available although. Sure, the 2 kissed and shared a second of ardour, however additionally they practically killed one another a handful of occasions. Let’s not neglect Rey would’ve killed Ben earlier within the film had she not been in a position to heal his wounds utilizing the Force. Yes, she healed the bodily scars, however being stabbed by somebody you kiss later actually has to mess together with your feelings.

Let’s be sincere, Rey and Ben had a poisonous relationship above any romance. Bringing Ben again would pressure the 2 to work by all of that, and I doubt all it took was Ben to speak to an imaginary manifestation of his father to be fully cleansed of a few of his First Order beliefs. There are simply too many unknowns and a whole lot of tough patches between these two to imagine all the things would’ve labored out okay ultimately, and Ben dwelling, I’d hope, would’ve confirmed that.

Ben Solo Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker

Keeping Ben Alive Wouldn’t Conclude The Skywalker Saga

Reylo love apart, would Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker be a conclusive finish to the Skywalker Saga if a dwelling descendant of the Skywalker household was round on the finish of issues? Leaving Ben Solo alive would’ve inspired followers to ask for extra adventures, which might in flip preserve the Skywalker Saga ongoing.

Granted, this is not the simplest argument to promote contemplating Rey named herself a Skywalker on the finish of the film, however the viewers is aware of the place she actually comes from. Leaving Ben alive leaves that familial connection to the Skywalkers and make it very laborious to, as Kylo Ren would say, “let the past die.” Star Wars motion pictures want to maneuver on previous the Skywalkers, and it might be actually laborious to do this with the son of Leia and Han nonetheless on the market on the earth. For that motive alone, it is a dangerous concept.

Related: Shrug? ‘Ben Solo Challenge’ Goes Viral As Star Wars Fans Honor Han Solo And Son’s Matching Moves

Star Wars: The Rise Of Skywalker remains to be out in theaters, simply in case anybody needs to dissect that Ben Solo exit once more. Stick with Sahiwal for extra on the film and for the most recent on what’s occurring in motion pictures and tv.


Leave a Comment