Shabnam, who strangled and killed seven family members, together with her mother and father, brother-in-law and ten-month-old nephew, is not going to be forgiven. The President rejected his mercy petition for the second time. Hanging is fastened.
Shabnam's village Bawankhedi is about thirty 5 km from my village. When the incident came about on 14 April 2008, I used to be in Jhansi, in Amar Ujala, the reporter. Heard learn from TV newspapers solely. Chief Minister Mayawati additionally went to the village. Amroha got here into the dialogue, I had nothing to do with the incident besides Amroha's identify, but saddened, embarrassed as effectively. Editor Vanshidhar Mishra ji and one or two individuals, who knew, I’m from Amroha, in any other case the remainder doesn’t imply a lot. <! –
I didn’t point out an excessive amount of, it was not even price mentioning. There shouldn’t be such merciless males within the land of my district, how a lady has grow to be so unhealthy!
Time handed by. Shabnam-Salim stored showing in newspapers, each of them have been hanged, solely from Amroha. The determination as much as Delhi was upheld. Then there was the method of apologizing. I don’t perceive why they’re desirous to dwell, neither to them, nor to those that are fearless. In this nation, so many individuals are committing suicide, it’s getting tough to persuade them, counseling occurs, don't die brother. And right here, these are the entire nation, the federal government, the legislation, that they need to die and they’re simply desirous to dwell, even when they dwell in bars. The Nirbhaya scandal ought to be given a first-degree kill, everyone seems to be saying, as a result of they did it just for lust and this can be a enormous false impression and drawback. With them, if there may be something like concord justice, no person will thoughts, perhaps.
But, see the twist, that the identical Hyderabad justice pertains to Shabnam. With the compelled argument that Shabnam did all this in Ishq, not in lust. I’ve by no means met Shabnam, there isn’t any cause to satisfy Salim. But, when Amroha returned a few years later. Dainik Jagran because the Chief of Bureau of Amroha. At the identical time, the then President Pravana Mukherjee dismissed Shabnam's mercy petition. Truth be advised, I didn’t prefer it. I went to Bawankhedi for the story. That cuttle home too. Full package deal, one web page given. Byline gave a narrative, the truth is, I additionally went for a similar story. Is there even a scope for Nafi who Shabnam could be forgiven sufficient to stay alive in jail, for his son, or for his son's identify. That child Taj could be very lovely, my Facebook friend too, now. Everyone obtained within the village, from the uncle, from Tau, the neighboring neighbors, whoever they have been, everybody mentioned that Shabnam was an excellent woman, was a instructor. However, all the pieces modified after that night time, even pondering.
Then requested, even after so a few years, I nonetheless hate Shabnam equally. Shabnam can’t be forgiven Believe me, all of them climbed on me. Was very offended. However, there are different causes for anger. I don't have that newspaper slicing, I didn't run Facebook a lot at the moment, however the title of the story was that Shabnam tu solely inform me the right way to forgive you. Love, anger, helplessness was all the pieces in it.
Today the identical recollections once more. But now I’m opening a bit of, writing freely. Those with the Nirbhaya scandal ought to get extreme punishment, ought to be a Nazir. But the Shabnam scandal will not be like them, the entire matter, the entire state of affairs, the entire feelings, the entire temper is completely different. Suppose, if Shabnam is left alive, then which unhealthy message will go within the society, it has already been defeated, many instances, what extra society, authorities or legislation will defeat it. What will you end, solely the physique, which is now not ready to do something.
Even if she stays alive, does any woman need to be like Shabnam, or wish to be alive. I’m not making full claims, but when she frees Shabnam, she is going to commit suicide herself, there will likely be so many taunts, as a result of our society itself is an excellent justice system. I’m not even saying to go away him, however quite that he ought to be stored alive for probably the most devious use of dehuman love and his unsuccessful proof. Everyone is aware of, killing her will not be an issue, not a problem, a woman tied up, a hangman can end her with a stroke of rope.
Of course, maintaining the woman alive for one night time could also be an issue and is extra of a problem than an issue, maybe society and the federal government ought to settle for this problem. Don't know what the outcomes will likely be. But this a lot is thought, neither will we grow to be small, nor will we be known as weak. Because it has been proved many instances, that we’re braver than Shabnam.
I’m nonetheless not in favor of Salim, as a result of if he refuses to help, Shabnam wouldn’t have completed so. Ultimately, he would say, in order for you, kill Shabnam, however some questions should stay alive, what’s love, what’s attraction, what’s insanity in love. Why is an acid assault, how do women survive. Can there even be a love in which there’s a provocation to kill their family members. Why is it wanted, why the 2 couldn’t get married, who might cease and why.
And additionally what’s the measure of our mercy, we put together one soldier for the military, in order that he can kill ten to twenty. Neither die, nor kill, know one another, nor has anybody dedicated immoral, indecent, indecent conduct. Then on each side of the border we additionally honor those that kill, as a result of the enemies who die are of the nation, these gears are afraid of snatching our home. Shabnam was afraid of not getting his home settled, so he obtained his personal individuals killed. Now they’re deciding the punishment, they’re additionally entitled to provide or to not be forgiven, from which Shabnam doesn’t even have any distance. The relaxation are tamashabin, in my manner, whose opinion doesn’t matter or is tied within the realm. Still suppose, can love, jealousy, hatred, kindness, forgiveness stay within the realm? What are these bulls?
(The author is a senior journalist, that is his private opinion)