‘The Good Doctor’: Why Fans Think [Spoiler] Might Not Actually Be Dead

by Jeremy Spirogis
‘The Good Doctor’: Why Fans Think [Spoiler] Might Not Actually Be Dead

The Good Doctor’s season three finale didn’t come and not using a few tears, which was to be anticipated with such a dramatic present. But the occasions that unfolded had been past what anybody would have anticipated — and left individuals extraordinarily confused and unhappy when the credit rolled. But with such a tragic episode, creator David Shore defined why he selected to kill off one of many present’s most vital characters — although we’re not completely satisfied he’s useless.

Warning: Spoilers forward!

'The Good Doctor' characters
‘The Good Doctor’ characters | Craig Sjodin/Walt Disney Television by way of Getty Images

‘The Good Doctor’ finale highlighted two main plot factors

Part 2 of the present’s season three finale positively saved the perfect for final by way of drama. Dr. Shaun Murphy was solely minutes away from drowning, and he lower his affected person’s leg off to save lots of each of their lives. The actions resulted in his finest friend, Lea, seeing him in a special gentle. Plus, Dr. Melendez, who had been hit by some rubble through the earthquake, realized that he had ischemic bowel illness — and it was extreme sufficient that there wasn’t a lot the docs might do.  

Shaun and Lea appear to have figured issues out

When Shaun was caught beneath the rubble in a room that was slowly filling up with water, it gave Lea loads of time to suppose. And the considered dropping Shaun made her understand that she’d been in love with him all alongside. The two have been mates because the present’s first season, although Shaun had at all times needed extra, regardless of getting into right into a relationship with Dr. Carly Lever for some time.

Once Shaun made it out alive, Lea realized that she by no means needed to danger dropping him once more. She approached him and kissed him, explaining how loopy she had been for not realizing her emotions from the beginning.

Paige Spara and Freddie Highmore, who play Lea and Shaun

Creator David Shore Explained Why Melendez Had to Die

Perhaps essentially the most poignant a part of the present occurred when Dr. Melendez was advised that he possible wasn’t going to stay — his inner bleeding had resulted in ischemic bowel illness, which the docs couldn’t repair.

In the present’s last moments, Dr. Claire Brown confesses that
she loves him, and he says it again. Later, Claire is seen leaving the room with
tears in her eyes, and Dr. Lim hugs her — Dr. Melendez is mendacity flat on the
hospital mattress within the background.

The present’s creator, David Shore, defined in an interview with Deadline that “people come and go” — and he felt Dr. Melendez was the precise alternative. “We wanted to lose a character that we would feel something about, and feel pain about, and certainly, he’s a character that so many of them have been in touch with,” Shore stated. “… You go forward [in the show], and people come and go. It’s a dynamic being, the show. New characters are going to come, old characters are going to leave.”

Is there an opportunity Melendez continues to be alive? Actor Nicholas Gonzalez hints there may be

Look, possibly we’re simply holding out hope as a result of he was so charming, however is there any risk Dr. Melendez continues to be alive? At the present’s finish, Claire walked out of his room, however there was by no means any express alternate that he had died — solely an insinuation.

Fans appeared to share the identical thought. “But for real, [Melendez’s] send off felt odd…like something wasn’t right…,” one consumer tweeted — actor Nicholas Gonzalez, who performs Melendez, retweeted the tweet. “… Until I see a funeral I don’t believe it!” one other consumer wrote in tweet that Gonzalez additionally retweeted.

The Good Doctor’s writers appear to like retaining followers on their toes, which is why we predict there could possibly be an ever-so-slight probability that Melendez had slipped right into a coma (presumably with demise to comply with), giving Dr. Murphy simply sufficient time to provide you with some one-in-a-million answer to save lots of his life. Well, possibly we’re dreaming, however we received’t know till season 4.

Leave a Comment