‘The Umbrella Academy’: Is Luther and Allison’s Relationship ‘Incest’?

by Jeremy Spirogis
Emmy Raver-Lampman as Allison Hargreeves on

The Netflix collection The Umbrella Academy has had two profitable seasons to date with a 3rd one on the best way. The present options some mind-bending components together with folks with superpowers and time-travel.

That might look like customary fare based mostly on what genres are fashionable in 2020, however there’s truly one component of the present that has raised eyebrows: Luther and Allison Hargreeves, adopted brother and sister, seem like in love on the present. Let’s take a more in-depth have a look at whether or not or not this relationship qualifies as incest. 

‘The Umbrella Academy’ is a Netflix hit

[embedded content material]

RELATED: ‘Umbrella Academy’ Season 2 Fans Will Love This HBO Sci-FI Series

Based on a comic book ebook, The Umbrella Academy follows the story of seven siblings. In 1989, 43 girls give delivery all internationally to exceptionally gifted youngsters.

These girls had no concept they had been pregnant beforehand. Seven of the kids are raised by a person named Reginald Hargreeves. Thirty years after drifting aside, the seven come again collectively once they’re grown to analyze their father’s loss of life, which they think would possibly homicide. 

Eventually, the group groups as much as try to cease the top of the world. When they’re unsuccessful in doing so, they journey again in time to repair the long run. Doing this makes issues much more difficult, as they bring about a few second apocalypse and reset their present timeline, erasing what that they had recognized in 2019. 

Luther and Allison have a posh relationship

Emmy Raver-Lampman as Allison Hargreeves on 'The Umbrella Academy' Season 2
Emmy Raver-Lampman as Allison Hargreeves on ‘The Umbrella Academy’ Season 2 | KALOHORIDIS/NETFLIX

RELATED: ‘The Umbrella Academy’ Season 3: Is Lila Recruiting Her Own Academy With Powered Kids?

The core of the present belongs to the Hargreeves siblings. Their relationships and interactions are what drive the story ahead and make it price watching. There’s no less than one pairing that has precipitated a little bit of controversy, nonetheless. 

While the present has drawn rave opinions and constructed up fairly a fan base, one component of it has drawn criticism. Two of the characters, Luther and Allison, have a burgeoning love story growing all through the collection.

While the 2 characters should not technically associated by blood, they’re adopted brother and sister and grew up in the identical family. This clearly presents one thing of an uncomfortable paradigm for followers watching the present. 

Is Luther and Allison’s relationship on ‘The Umbrella Academy’ incest?

[embedded content material]

In an interview with Digital Spy, collection creator Steve Blackman spoke in regards to the relationship and its considerably controversial nature. According to Blackman, it’s the connection continues to be in growth, so it’s laborious to pinpoint what it’s precisely.  

“But yes, are they siblings? Sort of….But they’re also not biologically related, and there’s such a puppy love story. You know, I don’t know if it’s real love. It might feel like real love to them. But it’s sort of a kid love from growing up together, and beautiful moments from their past when they hung out together.”

Is it incest? Perhaps not by the dictionary definition, however that doesn’t imply some viewers nonetheless don’t discover it objectionable. It additionally appears to be might be construed as insensitive to the plight of adopted siblings.

It’s additionally a bit extra difficult than one other well-known incestuous TV plotline: Jaime and Cersei Lannister on Game of Thrones. Whereas these characters had been depicted as villainous — although Jaime ultimately grew to become a extra sympathetic character — Luther and Allison are characters the viewers is supposed to get behind. 

So is the Luther/Allison storyline morally unsuitable? It’s troublesome to say, however the query itself virtually misses the purpose of making compelling artwork. The relationship actually presents a difficult dilemma for the characters, and whereas it could be uncomfortable for some to observe, putting characters into robust conditions is what makes for nice drama.

Without an inner battle, the present would fall flat. Creating a successful TV present typically imply making robust narrative decisions that aren’t simple for the characters to take care of. The Luther/Allison relationship will surely qualify for that. 

Leave a Comment