‘This Is Us’: A Disturbing New Theory Connects The Past and Present In the Worst Way

by Jeremy Spirogis
‘This Is Us’: A Disturbing New Theory Connects The Past and Present In the Worst Way

The return of This Is Us surprised all. Lots of brand-new information surfaced while simultaneously starting brand-new threads to concern. Among the largest “what just happened” moments occurred with Randall (Sterling K. Brown). Now, fans think there may be a connection between a traumatic circumstance in past times together with event at the conclusion of Tuesday’s episode. Here’s the most recent [disturbing] This Is Us theory.

[Spoilers for This Is Us Season 4 midseason premiere below]

‘This Is Us’ caused more questions

'This Is Us'
Chrissy Metz as Kate | Ron Batzdorff/NBC/NBCU Photo Bank via Getty Images

[Last chance: Spoilers for This Is Us Season 4 midseason premiere]

In the midseason premiere of This Is Us, “Light and Shadows,” doctors investigated Rebecca’s (Mandy Moore) memory dilemmas for responses. Despite Miguel’s (Jon Huertas) minor irritation, Randall called in a favor, while he has a tendency to do, using the most useful neurologist in the nation.

Miguel blogged off Rebecca’s memory lapses as “getting older” and thought Randall had been overstepping, but ultimately apologized.

Tests suggested Rebecca is, in reality dealing with the increased loss of thoughts. The level of how dreadful her problem will worsen will unfold in due time.

Kate (Chrissy Metz) and Toby (Chris Sullivan) however deal with an uphill fight in their wedding. After Kate confronted Toby about his commitment with CrossFit “friend,” Lady Kryptonite, things got uncomfortable — fast.

Toby confessed he changed health clubs to prevent the girl (whom attempted to kiss him most likely). He additionally stated their length had been for their child, Jack’s visual disability. Some worry Toby has a strained relationship with both Kate and Toby for their failure to get in touch with either when Jack struggles with picture in the long run.

Kevin (Justin Hartley) found their fantasy woman, Lizzie (Sophia Bush). He offered her a magical (unrealistic) time before she disclosed she had been hitched.

Meanwhile, flashbacks of Jack (Milo Ventimiglia) and Rebecca’s (Mandy Moore) love tale disclosed that Rebecca’s father intervened to push Jack away for not “good enough.” It only made Rebecca love Jack much more.

All with this, nevertheless, became the precipice for just what would occur to Randall within the last surprising moments of this event.

Is Randall hallucinating?

Once Randall returns house to Pennsylvania, he checked on Beth (Susan Kelechi Watson) and three daughters have been asleep. Stressed because of the body weight of his mother’s memory-related dilemmas, life within the community workplace, together with pressures to be the very best spouse and parent within the world (like their parent, Jack), Randall seems only a little away from kinds.

When he walks downstairs to obtain one cup of liquid, an armed intruder appears within the cooking area. The episode finished with Randall drenched in worry. Naturally, followers have got all the ideas in regards to what this moment implied and just who the intruder might be.

Executive producer, Isaac Aptaker, recommended Randall’s failing psychological state is unexpectedly daunting. The intruder, whether real or hallucinated, could be the manifestation of most Randall usually takes.

“It is going to be the straw that leads to Randall to have to re-evaluate what’s going on with his own mental health and how much he can handle,” Aptaker informed Entertainment Weekly.

Brown also hinted that the idea of some other description could show real. He hallucinated before and recently ignored Beth’s plea about treatment.

“Fogelman and our writers came up with a storyline that I think is quite compelling,” Sterling stated through the recent Television Critics Association winter months hit trip.

“It allows us to further delve into Randall’s mental health and how he takes care of himself — what’s right and what’s wrong about how he takes care of himself and how he could potentially do a better job of that.”

It’s plausible that Randall breaks from all the stress, but This Is Us fans think there might be another link.

Fans believe those two things tend to be relevant with regards to Randall’s alarming situation

This Is Us won’t write what’s expected. Because with this, some can’t assistance but believe away from box.

“What if the intruder is Kate’s record store ex?” one lover blogged on Reddit.

It’s maybe not a totally impossible situation. At this aspect, audiences however don’t understand the extent of Marc’s (Austin Abrams) commitment with [teen] Kate, Randall, Kevin, and Rebecca.

Showrunners formerly hinted at Marc’s toxic, perhaps abusive relationship with Kate, and visitors weren’t to thinking about him talking about Randall as “Randy,” when you look at the many disrespectful fashion.

That stated, there may be even worse items to come for Kate. Randall, being the great bro he’s, could easily get also included, causing Marc to make on every person. Marc could perhaps hold a grudge for decades. Others recognize.

“Tobias Jelinek is credited as The Intruder on IMDB. Austin Abrams played Kate’s teen boyfriend, Marc. Not sure how likely the theory could be but I could definitely buy a distinct resemblance between the two actors. Same eye color, similar facial structure, complexion, etc. I wouldn’t rule it out entirely as a possibility,” another lover included.

Another lover echoed the idea saying, “This was my first thought too. I really think it’s someone Randall knows. I’ve thought about this mysterious ex after almost every episode, and I wonder if this is him coming back after being in jail or something.”

Via Twitter, followers tend to be adding all variants with this principle, among others. Which one will show real? We’ll need to hold back until the Randall-centric event shows all.

This Is Us airs Tuesday at 9 p.m. ET on NBC.

Leave a Comment