Why Comic-Accurate Superhero Costumes Only Make Brief Cameos within the MCU

by Jeremy Spirogis
Kevin Feige, Taika Waititi and Natalie Portman

Movie superhero costumes haven’t been correct to the comic-book variations for years. The unique 1978 Superman with Christopher Reeve marked one of many relative few instances {that a} film costume strongly resembled the one within the comics. Four phrases: Nipples on the Batsuit. 

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has been relatively intelligent in the best way it makes use of costumes that appear to be the comedian e-book variations: they make fast cameos, such because the Scarlet Witch costume that seems in a single shot of the WandaVision preview. 

Marvel followers discuss film vs print costumes

Kevin Feige, Taika Waititi and Natalie Portman
Kevin Feige, Taika Waititi and Natalie Portman | Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images for Disney

The topic of superhero costumes got here up on Reddit the place a fan posted three photos of MCU costumes that truly seemed just like the comedian variations: the WandaVision outfit, Power Man from the Netflix sequence and Captain America’s star-spangled get-up in The First Avenger.

Fans identified that Spider-Man’s fundamental outfit seems to be comedian correct. Thanks to Stark Industries, nonetheless, even Spidey’s costume has a lifetime of its personal with all its devices. 

‘”(Director Sam) Raimi and (Marc) Webb’s Spider-man costumes are 1 to 1 with the comics. Raimi bought it so proper that Webb made modifications for modifications’ sake for the primary swimsuit,” one fan commented, referring to earlier Spider-Man films that weren’t a part of the MCU. 

Another fan said, “I personally don’t want comedian accuracy. As lengthy because the character is recognizably him/herself, I’m okay with it. In some circumstances, not going comedian correct is healthier. One huge instance of that is Captain America. It was such an impressed selection in The First Avenger to make use of his comedian correct look when he’s only a poster boy/mascot, after which transfer to one thing nearer to a soldier’s outfit when he formally joins the combat. Cap’s a soldier. He would costume like a soldier.”

Examples of the modifications from comedian e-book to film

[embedded content]

The first X-Men film in 2000 was what actually kickstarted the wave of superhero films that also washes over Hollywood, and that film truly poked enjoyable on the printed variations of the costumes. It merely wouldn’t do for Hugh Jackman to go parading round in tight yellow spandex, so he will get a modern darkish outfit. 

Sometimes one film incarnation that is kind of comic-accurate provides method to one thing extra “realistic” wanting. The 2003 Daredevil film featured a fancy dress that was basically comics correct, however when the Netflix sequence got here alongside, the costume designer caught with an all-black do-it-yourself aesthetic that will make it more durable for potential dangerous guys to identify.

The total idea appears to be that what seems to be good within the comics seems to be goofy within the films. Aquaman is likely one of the extra excessive transformations from web page to display screen. 

For years, folks pointed and laughed at his orange Super Friends stand up, so he bought a wholly completely different look extra befitting of Jason Momoa within the 2018 film. 

Why do film costumes differ from the comics?

[embedded content]

The query of why film costumes differ from e-book costumes was addressed on a Stack Exchange dialogue. One particular person identified that as “iconic” as some comedian costumes could also be, they alter within the books generally greater than they do within the films. 

“Lastly, whilst you may be correct in stating that Wolverine’s yellow and blue costume is ‘iconic’, it’s not his only costume, and it has changed several times over since his first appearance back in 1974,” the fan stated. 

It may also be one thing so simple as altering instances. When Supergirl was launched on the web page, her basic costume was tight spandex with a really brief pink miniskirt. The 1984 film adhered to this look, however when the present WB sequence featured this costume within the first season, it was handled as a joke, with Kara declaring she couldn’t presumably put on one thing that skimpy.

Subsequent seasons saved the skirt however gave Kara a fancy dress much like the look seen in Man of Steel. The costume was redone once more within the present season, with Supergirl sporting tights as a substitute of the skirt.  

Leave a Comment